Skip to content
January 26, 2011 / Ben


I’m distracted this week by the campaign to #saveH2G2.

What is H2G2, and why should you care?

H2G2 is one of the community sites shivering under the BBC’s axe. It was bought by the BBC on the 25th January 2001 and a decade later less one day the BBC announced it will be “disposed of”. “Disposed of”, note, not “closed” because there is something here of great vitality.

H2G2 is an open access writing site, where you’ll get thoughtful and constructive feedback on what you write through a system of writing workshops and peer review and where you can make friends (and enemies) that you’ll value for life.

H2g2'S new front page - the new skin is a bit buggy - oh the irony

H2g2'S new front page - the new skin is a bit buggy - oh the irony

But whenever I try to say more I just end up saying what it isn’t:

  • It’s not Wikipedia even though it predated it as an experiment in user-generated content and on-line communities being founded in 1999 by the late, tall, Douglas Adams as “the earth edition of the HitchHiker’sGuide to the Galaxy”.
  • But it’s not a fan site.  It really isn’t.  “Hootizens” respect DNA, but  don’t revere him.
  • It’s not a blog-and-comment site though users have their own “journals” and create “entries” with “conversations” hanging off them.
  • It’s not a creative writing site though there is a lot of creative writing on it.
  • It’s not even primarily a social network though it predates just about all of the ones still standing,  and it’s not  “a small town in cyberspace” though that is how I’ve described it for years. Well, a decade, I guess.

And after –  or because of – it’s indescribable past it now faces an uncertain future.  Nick Reynolds (Social Media Executive, BBC Online) and Jim Lynn (who developed the original platform) both express cryptic goodwill and commitment to the community.  But it’s hard to see who’d want to buy the site.

The future then and now

One of the great wistfulnesses about h2g2 is the difference between what it could have been and what it was.  Douglas Adams was an astonishing visionary about all things online…

49 minutes of uncanny prescience.
Where we are now predicted way back then
by Douglas Adams in 1990.

… but  the BBC never really took first mover’s advantage in any of the then-cool things that h2g2 was first to have.  And now the BBC are disposing of what has become a site that even those of us who love it have to admit is quaint.

Community action

And how have the h2g2 community responded?

By and large, pretty well.  As Nick Reynolds said:

H2G2 is the best behaved and most civilised community I’ve ever encountered. The way that you have reacted to the news is a great credit to you.

Members of the community have gathered in a Google Group called the h2g2 Continuity Consortium (h2g2c2 – geddit) and are trying to put the show on right here in the barn… er… server farm.

Some of the comment is skeptical,  but slightly to my surprise, I think we’ll succeed, partly because we are not trying to buy the site off the BBC. We want to ensure that the best possible group runs the site, but are rather reluctantly aware that group might end up being us.

We will succeed in the short term because the BBC is not pulling the plug immediately, because we’ve been overwhelmed by offers of server space, by advice from people who’ve done the same thing in other online communities, and by practical support from within the community.

And I think we will succeed in the long term because we are so old.  We know each other.   We’ve fought, flirted, argued and made up across timezones and forums for a long time.  We’ve danced at each others’ weddings, stood godparents to each others children, and grown from being school-children to adults, collecting relevant (and gloriously irrelevant) skills, experiences and qualifications in the process.

We know how the internet works, how online communities and social media and web servers and all the things that Douglas Adams predicted but the rest of us took ten years to find out.

And best of all, it turns out that we are not just a bunch of quirky names and flirty posts, but also a bunch of coders and project managers, change programme leaders, doctors and people claiming disability benefit or who are just plain on the dole.  We have skilz and we have time.  (A lot of the former and a bit of the latter).

In management speak, we’ve Stormed (ye gods how we’ve stormed) Formed and Normed (and abNormed, but that’s a different story).

Now we are ready to Perform.


  1. Egon / Jan 27 2011 12:31 am

    I had never seen Hyperland before. I’m quite enjoying it.

    • Ben Warsop / Jan 28 2011 12:42 am

      I think it’s awesome. And – get this – it predates Tim Berners-Lee and the Browser by 4 years. It’s shocking to me it’s not better known.

  2. Colm / Jan 27 2011 7:21 am

    Great post, Ben. I must run over there to see what the fuss is all about.

    When you mentioned “small town on the Internet”, I had to laugh. I am an elder citizen then, who established himself at the founding of the town but headed off to the city, and comes back occasionally to see how the locality is getting on.

    Now the bypass has been planned and the bulldozers are on their way.

  3. Teuchter / Jan 27 2011 8:12 am

    Good post, Ben. I hope Something Can Be Done.

    Are they bulldozers, Colm – or is it a Vogon Constructor Fleet?

    • Colm / Jan 27 2011 10:37 am

      Both, I guess! Kind of ironic, don’t you think?

      • Ben Warsop / Jan 28 2011 12:44 am

        I really am very hopeful. None of it’s that hard. Time-consuming, yes. But not actually hard.


  4. nighthoover / Jan 27 2011 10:14 pm

    It certainly sucks…

    • Ben Warsop / Jan 28 2011 12:43 am

      Takes one to know one.

      *Blows nighthoover a kiss*

  5. Bel / Jan 27 2011 11:29 pm

    Great post, Ben. Very apt description of what h2g2 is not. :-D
    No really, it is so hard to explain what it is, not only to outsiders.
    h2g2 rocks, and we shall overcome.

  6. Stewart / Jan 28 2011 2:07 pm

    Who said the next war will be fought in cyberspace? I know this isn’t BUT it is a fight for survival. Good luck & if love & peace still mean anything, then you have both from me. X

  7. dragonqueen / Jan 29 2011 6:57 pm

    There are occasions when i’d like to be more of my cyber me – throwing flames and eating Th-r-d-yites and other misfits.

  8. elentari86 / Feb 4 2011 5:46 pm

    I wish I was as confident as you are! Fingers crossed, though!

  9. Business Analysis Courses / Oct 14 2011 1:04 am

    I really liked and shared this post. Keep up the good work Douglas. :-)

  10. Business Analyst Jobs / Sep 4 2012 11:54 am

    Great post on a site well worth saving.


  1. #saveH2G2 (via Thinking about it…) « Verbosity

Comments are closed.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: